PEER REVIEW PRESENTATION
By J. Monroe Laborde, MD, MS
Presented in the Journal of the Southern Orthopaedic
Association
12(2):60-65, 2003
Forefoot ulcers are common complications of neuropathy.
Trans-tibial amputation too often becomes necessary when progressive
infections develops secondary to ulcers of the forefoot. Tendon lengthening
appears to be an effective treatment for planar forefoot ulcers in
patients with neuropathy and forefoot ulceration,
Introduction
Diabetic foot problems are the leading cause of amputation1.
Five toten percent of diabetic patients will require amputation1.
Over fifty thousand amputations occur annually in diabetics in the
United States.2 Eighty-five perrcent of lower-extremity amputations
are preceded by foot ulcers in patients with diabetes mellitus.2
Guyton and Saltzman3 discussed in detail the etiology
of foot ulcers in diabetic patients. In the absence of large-vessel
disease, diabetic foot disease results from the combination of neuropathy
and abnormal mechanical stress.3 Deformity that increases pressure
on a portion of the foot can instigate ulceration in a patient with
diabetic neuropathy.3 Peripheral neuropathy results in loss of protective
sensation and lack ofrecognition of repetitive mechanical stress which
often cause forefoot ulcers in diabetic patients.4
Daniels5 stated that diabetic neuropathy contributes
to the development of equinus contracture of the ankle which increases
pressure on the forefoot. The high forefoot pressure is consistent
with the most common locations of foot ulcers being the plantar surface
of the first three metatarsal heads and the hallux5.
Foot ulcers can cause deep spreading infection which
can result in leg amputation.5 Prevention and care of foot ulcers
would prevent most leg amputations in diabetics.5
Patients with a history of foot ulcers have abnormally
high pressures at healed ulcer sites.6 Plantar foot ulcers occur at
sites of high pressure.7 The combination of neuropathy and equinus
contracture have been implicated in the cause of forefoot ulcers8.
Reducing the risk of neuropathic ulceration of the foot should be
accomplished by decreasing pressure on the forefoot.6 Pressure relief
has been accomplished by shoe modification, total contact casts and
Achilles tendon lengthening.9 Achilles tendon lengthening has been
shown to promote healing of chronic foot ulcers in patients with neuropathy.8,10
Healing occurred even in patients who did not heal in total contact
cast with less ulcer recurrence.10 Dorsiflexion metatarsal osteotomy
also is effective in healing chronic neuropathic forefoot ulcers but
with a much higher complication rate11.
Successful treatment of ulcers and prevention of amputation
areimportant objectives for those who manage patients with neuropathic
forefoot ulcers. This report describes the results of a group of patients
who had forefoot ulcers treated with tendon lengthenings.
Materials and Methods
Between May of 1995 and October of 2001, sixteen patients
who had neuropathy and one or more plantar forefoot ulcers agreed
to surgical tendon lengthening. Ulcers of metatarsal heads we treated
with lengthening of the gastrocnemius-soleus mechanism. The Vulpius
technique12 was used, transecting the aponeurotic tendon of the gastrocnemius
and soleus in the mid calf (see Figure 1). The patient’s ankle
was then placed in neutral in a short leg walking cast for six weeks.
Toe ulcers were treated with toe flexor tendon tenotomy percutaneously
at the proximal phalanx. First toe ulcers had both procedures at the
same time if the patient would agree. Patients were allowed to go
home the day of surgery unless they were in the hospital for another
reason.
The Vulpius procedure lengthens the gastrocnemius tendon
and soleus aponeurosis proximal to the actual Achilles tendon. The
lengthening effect on the ankle and foot is the same as tendon lengthening
and the terms gastrocnemius-soleus lengthening by Vulpius technique,
Vulpius type Achilles tendon lengthening and Vulpius procedure are
used interchangeably.
The amount of active ankle dorsiflexion with the knee
in full extension was measured pre-operatively with a goniometer.
Pulses were measured by palpation of dorsalis pedis and posterior
tibial arteries
Ulcers were graded using Wagner’s 13 classification:
grade one is superficial; two is deep, extending to ligament, tendon,
joint capsule, fascia or bone; three is grade two with infection (abscess,
osteitis or osteomyelitis); four is gangrene of the toe or forefoot;
five is gangrene of the entire foot. Grades three to five were not
included unless grade three could be transformed to grade one or two
by antibiotics. Patients with prior gangrene of toes, abscess and/or
osteomyelitis had been treated in the past by toe amputation, metatarsal
head resection, abscess drainage and/or debridement by other physicians,
but were not excluded from this study.
The size of the ulcer was measured and duration of the
ulcer was obtained from the patient. The presence of neuropathy was
determined by the nylon monofilament test.14
Results
The patients were assigned a number in the order they
had their first tendon lengthening surgery (see table). All sixteen
patients had neuropathy by monofilament test. Fourteen had diabetes
mellitus. Patient number four had neuropathy after lumbar surgery
and number six had alcoholic neuropathy.
Ages of patients ranged from forty-four to eighty-one
at the time of surgery, and averaged sixty-one. There were eight males
and eight females. Eleven had palpable pedal pulses and five did not.
All patients who had a Vulpius procedure for metatarsal ulcers had
ankle contracture with inability to dorsiflex the ankle beyond neutral
(zero degrees dorsiflexion or less).
Patient number one had ulcers bilaterally, and had Vulpius
procedure bilaterally eleven months apart. The first metatarsal ulcers
healed but a transfer ulcer of the first toe developed unilaterally
four months after the second Vulpius procedure. This transfer ulcer
also healed after the toe flexor tendon was cut.
There were twenty surgeries on nineteen ulcers in sixteen
patients. Patient nine had a second surgery (Vulpius procedure) when
his first toe ulcer did not heal in six weeks after toe tenotomy.
Nine ulcers were grade one and ten were grade two. Seven patients
(with eight ulcers) had infection treated with antibiotics. Once infection
appeared to be under control, tendon lengthenings were performed.
Four patients had had one or more toes previously removed.
Patient number six had had her first metatarsal head removed and patient
number five had the first, second and third metatarsal heads (and
the first and third toes) removed in the past. Patient five had a
particularly extensive ulcer (Figure 2). This ulcer healed after Vulpius
procedure and the patient did not have any recurrent ulcers and the
skin of her foot was intact when she died of medical problems eighteen
months later.
The diameter of thirteen ulcers was one centimeter
or under and two were over three centimeters. Six ulcers were located
under the first metatarsal head or stump, six under the first toe,
three under the second toe, one under the base of the fifth metatarsal
and one under each of the second, third and fourth metatarsal head.
Patient number nine with a first toe ulcer initially
consented to only percutaneous release of that toe flexor. The ulcer
did not heal in six weeks but healed later after Vulpius procedure
was performed. Because of the experience with patients one (first
toe ulcer developed unilaterally on side of Vulpius procedure alone
and not on side of both Vulpius and tenotomy of toe) and patient nine
(first toe ulcer not healing after toe flexor cut and healing after
Vulpius procedure), Vulpius procedure was recommended in addition
to toe flexor lengthening for later first toe ulcers.
Ulcer duration prior to surgery ranged from one month
to seven years (average fourteen months). Most patients had had unsuccessful
attempts to heal the ulcer with stretching exercises, decreased weight
bearing, debridement, and shoe modification.
In all patients but number nine (discussed above) and
eleven, the ulcers healed in less than six weeks. Patient eleven was
on dialysis and had Charcot arthritis of midfoot and severe arterial
insufficiency. The ulcer did not heal and he later developed gangrene
of the foot and required amputation.
All incisions healed primarily without any infections.
There were no ulcer recurrences or transfer metatarsal head ulcers.
There were two transfer ulcers in toes (patient one, first toe; patient
fourteen, third toe) both of which later healed after toe tenotomy.
No new deformities developed after the tendon lengthenings.
Follow up was in person for fourteen procedures and
by phone for six. The follow up ranged from six months to seventy-five
months excluding patient nine’s first surgery (Vulpius procedure
six weeks after toe tenotomy not healing first toe ulcer). The average
follow up for the other nineteen procedures was twenty-eight months.
There were three complications in addition to those
described above. Patient number one had a pulmonary embolus over three
months after the first surgery, but recovered completely. Patient
number thirteen developed a heel ulcer post operatively, which healed
almost completely with no additional problems. Patient sixteen had
an open dislocation of her fifth toe treated with amputation.
Discussion
The number of patients and the length of follow up
of some of the patients are both small enough to consider the results
preliminary. The relatively high rate of ulcer healing, amputation
prevention and relatively low complication rate help compensate for
the weaknesses of this study.
The association of gastrocnemius-soleus contracture,
neuropathy, and chronic ulceration of the forefoot in this group of
patients was previously reported by Yosipovitch and Sheskin8 and by
Lin, Lee and Wapner.10 The patients of Lin et al who had Achilles
tendon lengthening all had flexion contractures which was also the
case in this series. The high rate of successful healing of forefoot
ulcers in prior studies, seven of eight 8 and fourteen of fifteen10,
was similar to this report, eighteen of twenty. Lin et al’s
one failure was due to osteomyelitis of the metatarsal head.10 Patient
nine’s ulcer failed to heal after tenotomy of first toe but
healed after Vulpius procedure. Patient eleven’s failure to
heal was felt to be due to a combination of peripheral vascular disease,
ulcer infection and Charcot arthritis. Yosipovitch and Sheskin8 had
three ulcer recurrences in four to five year follow up. Both Lin et
al.10 and this study found no ulcer recurrences, obvious gait problems,
or new deformities after tendon lengthening. The absence of recurrent
ulcers in this series compares favorably with the reported recurrence
rate of foot ulcers in 558 diabetic patients after one, three and
five years of 34%, 61% and 70% of patients.15 Lin et al’s10
average follow up was seventeen months, compared to twenty-eight months
in this study.
Dorsiflexion metatarsal osteotomy also had a high rate
of successful healing of neuropathic forefoot ulcers (21 of 22).11
There was, however, a 68% complication rate with seven patients developing
acute Charcot disease, three developing midfoot ulcers, three deep
wound infections, two transfer ulcers under adjacent metatarsal heads,
and one below knee amputation. This study revealed no new Charcot
disease, mid foot ulcers or wound infections. There were three transfer
lesions, a first toe ulcer in patient one, a third toe ulcer in patient
sixteen and the heel ulcer in patient thirteen. Two patients subsequently
required amputation for gangrene (seven and eleven), but none for
progressive infection.
Gangrene was felt to be a contraindication to tendon
lengthening. Patients without pulses, however, were felt to be potentially
salvageable since there were no incision problems and ulcers healed
in all but one of the patients without pulses. Quantitation of vascularity
in patients without pulses might be helpful in predicting success
but was not done in this study.
Lin et al. lengthened the Achilles tendon by Hoke’s
method16 of hemisection at three levels of the tendon. Yospovitch
and Sheskin used the subcutaneous tenotomy method of Strohmeyer.17
The author chose the Vulpius technique12 because of his prior favorable
experience with this technique in children with cerebral palsy (less
over correction and incision problems). Sharrard and Bernstein 18
recommended gastrocnemius recession in cerebral palsy patients who
lacked passive ankle extension beyond a right angle. They preferred
this technique to Achilles tendon lengthening because of less recurrence
and incision problems in their series and because they felt under
correction was preferable to over correction. Which technique for
tendon lengthening is best for forefoot ulcers has not yet been determined
and at this point should probably be left to the discretion of the
surgeon.
The purpose of tendon lengthening is to decrease stress
on the area of ulceration. Tenotomy of the toe flexor tendons is done
to decrease stress on the plantar surface of the toe. The lengthening
of the gastrocnemius-soleus mechanism should decrease stress on the
plantar forefoot and the area of ulceration. Armstrong et al9 confirmed
that Achilles lengthening does in fact decrease pressure on the forefoot
and recommended the procedure as an adjunctive therapeutic and prophylactic
measure to reduce the risks of neuropathic ulceration.
Another study should be done to determine if daily
calf stretching can prevent progression of callouses to ulcers in
patients with neuropathy, and can prevent gastrocnemius-soleus contracture,
forefoot callouses and ulceration in diabetics if started before the
development of these problems. Since calf stretching might help and
probably would not harm diabetic patients, it now seems reasonable
to recommend prophylactic calf stretching to them.
Conclusion
Further investigation is needed to confirm the results
of this preliminary report. The results of this series of patients
suggests that lengthening of the tendon-muscle unit is effective treatment
for forefoot ulceration. These lengthenings would not be expected
to prevent amputation in patients with severe peripheral vascular
disease. This procedure usually prevents progression of neuropathic
forefoot ulceration to infection and subsequent amputation. A follow
up study is under way to better document these findings with more
Bibliography
1. McDermott JE, ed. The Diabetic Foot. Rosemont , IL
: American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgery;1995.
2. Reiber GE, Boyko EJ, Smith DG. Lower extremity foot
ulcers and amputations in diabetics. In: Harris MI, Cowie CC, Stern
MP, Boyko EJ, Reiber GE, Bennett PH, eds. Diabetes in America. 2nd
ed., Washington , DC : US Government Printing Office, 408-28 (DHHS
pub. No. 95-1468). 1995.
3. Guyton GP, Saltzman CL. The diabetic foot, basic
mechanisms of disease. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. 2001;83A(7):
1084-96.
4. Cavanagh PR, chair consensus panel. Consensus development
conference on diabetic wound care, American Diabetic Association.
Diabetes Care. 1999; 22(8): 1354-60.
5. Daniels TR. Diabetic foot ulcerations: an overview.
Ostomy/Wound Management. 1998; 44(9): 76-84.
6. Armstrong DG, Stern S, Lavery LA, Harkless LB. Is
prophylactic diabetic foot surgery dangerous? Journal of Foot and
Ankle Surgery. 1996; 35(6): 585-589.
7. Katoulis EC, Boulton AJ, Raptis SA. The role of diabetic
neuropathy and high plantar pressures in the pathogenisis of foot
ulceration. Horm. Metab. Res. 1996; 28: 159-164.
8. Yosipovitch Z, Sheskin J. Subcutaneous Achilles tenotomy
in the treatment of perforating ulcer of the foot in leprosy. International
J. Leprosy and other Mycobact. Dis. 1971; 39: 631-632.
9. Armstrong DG, Shea SS, Nguyen H, Harkless LB. Lengthening
of the Achilles tendon in diabetic patients who are at high risk for
ulceration of the foot. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. 1999; 81-A
(4): 535-8.
10. Lin SS, Lee TH, Wapner KL. Plantar forefoot ulceration
with equinus deformity of the ankle in diabetic patients; the effect
of tendo-Achilles lengthening and total contact casting. Orthopedics.
1996; 19 (5): 465-474.
11. Fleischili JE, Anderson RB, Davis WH, Dorsiflexion
metatarsal osteotomy for treatment of recalcitrant diabetic neuropathic
ulcers. Foot and Ankle International. 1999; 20 (2): 80-85.
12. Vulpius O, Stoffel A. Orthopaedische Operationslehve,
ed.2, Stuttgart , 1920, Ferdinand Enke.
13. Wagner FW. The diabetic foot. Orthopedics. 1987;
10 (1): 163-72.
14. Birke JA, Sims DS. Plantar sensory threshold in
the ulcerative foot. Leprosy Rev. 1986; 57: 261-7.
15. Apelgrist J. Larsson J, Agardh CD. Long-term prognosis
for diabetic patients with foot ulcers. Journal of Internal Medicine.
1993; 223: 485-91.
16. Hsu JD, Hsu CL, in Jass MH (editor). Disorders of
the Foot. Philidelphia, W. B. Sanders (01) 1952.
17. Strohmeyer L, in Rang M (editor). Anthology of orthpaedics.
Edinburgh, E9S, Livingstone, Ltd.; 1996: 212-215.
18. Sharrard WJW, Bernstein S. Equinus deformity in
cerebral palsy. Journal
of Bone and Joint Surgery. 1972; 54B: 272-276